Send us a text

M. Night Shyamalan is a normal director who everyone has normal opinions about, and when the man wants to, he can really construct a moment that makes you shit your pants. But what are his best six scares, and in what order? The American people demand to know.

Luckily, the crew from the How I Met Your Monster podcast - Danny Salemme, Casey Brewer, and Zach Wincik - stop by to help put the list together. And this isn't some boring everyone throw out your personal favorites list bullshit. No, the American people deserve better, and they get better, because everyone must come to a consensus on what the ranking of Shyamalan's six best scares are.

Things get spicy as debates are had over what's a scarier film overall - The Sixth Sense or Signs. What scare from The Village seems distinct enough like it could wind up on this list? Do any scary moments from more recent films like The Visit or Old wind up here, or is the past where the true gold lies? Is George Bush an alien?

The only way to find out is to find out, so get spooky and listen now!

Follow Danny on Instagram and Letterboxd and check out his official website!

Follow Zach on Instagram!

Follow Casey on Instagram!

Follow How I Met Your Monster on Instagram!

Nick on Instagram
Nick on Letterboxd

Elusive | Official Website
Elusive | Stream Free on Tubi
Elusive | Rent/Buy on Prime Video